Mistakes to Avoid When Filing an ADA Claim in New York
Reviewed for accuracy by the ADAhelp team before publishing. ADAhelp is not a law firm; legal work is handled by independent New York attorneys.

Seven mistakes that kill New York ADA claims: missed deadlines, federal-only filings, thin evidence, forum traps, and what to do instead. Free case check.
Most New York disability claims do not fail because the discrimination did not happen. They fail because of a missed deadline, a piece of evidence that was never saved, or a complaint filed under the wrong law with the wrong agency. The mistakes to avoid when filing an ADA claim are procedural almost every time, which is the frustrating part and also the hopeful part: procedure is something you can get right.
This guide covers the seven errors that most often end a claim before anyone evaluates the merits, and what to do instead. It is written for claimants in New York, where the state and city human rights laws give you considerably more than the federal ADA does, provided you actually use them.
Short answer: The costliest mistakes are missing the filing deadline, relying on the federal ADA alone when New York State and City law is what provides money damages, failing to document the barrier or the request at the time it happened, filing with an agency without understanding that it can forfeit your right to go to court, and never making a written accommodation request before complaining about the denial. Each one is avoidable, and each one is usually fatal.
Key Takeaways
- Deadlines are the leading cause of death for New York disability claims: 300 days for an EEOC charge, three years at the State Division of Human Rights for acts on or after February 15, 2024, and generally one year at the NYC Commission on Human Rights.
- The federal ADA mainly gets a barrier fixed. The NYSHRL and NYCHRL are what put money in your hands.
- Filing a NYSHRL complaint with the Division of Human Rights generally forfeits your right to bring the same claim in court.
- In employment cases, a written accommodation request usually has to come before the denial you want to complain about.
- Evidence captured on the day is worth many times evidence reconstructed from memory a year later.
Mistake 1: Missing the Filing Deadline
Every other mistake on this list can sometimes be repaired. This one usually cannot.
The clocks are different for every agency, and they start on the date of the discriminatory act, not the date you realized it was discrimination or the date you finished trying to resolve it internally:
- EEOC: generally 300 days in New York for a federal ADA employment charge.
- New York State Division of Human Rights: for acts occurring on or after February 15, 2024, generally three years.
- NYC Commission on Human Rights: generally one year from the discriminatory act, and three years for gender-based harassment.
- Court: NYSHRL and NYCHRL claims generally carry a three-year statute of limitations.
Two traps inside the traps. First, complaining to HR does not pause any of these clocks. Internal grievance processes can run for months while the external deadline quietly expires. Second, if you receive an EEOC Notice of Right to Sue, you have a hard 90 days to file in federal court, and nothing extends it. Our New York ADA deadlines guide walks through each clock and when it starts.
Mistake 2: Relying on the Federal ADA Alone
People file under the ADA because it is the law they have heard of. Then they learn what it actually delivers.
- ADA Title III, which covers restaurants, stores, medical offices, and other places of public accommodation, gives a private plaintiff injunctive relief and attorney's fees. It does not provide compensatory damages to you personally. You can get the ramp built. You cannot get paid for the year you could not get into the building.
- ADA Title I, which covers employment, does allow compensatory and punitive damages, but caps them by employer size, from $50,000 for the smallest covered employers up to $300,000 for the largest. It also only reaches employers with 15 or more employees.
New York law is where the leverage is. The NYSHRL applies to employers of every size, defines disability far more broadly than the ADA with no "substantial limitation" requirement, and imposes no equivalent cap on compensatory damages. The NYCHRL applies to employers with four or more employees, is required to be construed more liberally than its federal and state counterparts, and permits punitive damages in appropriate cases.
Filing a claim that invokes only the federal statute, when the same facts support a state and city claim, can cost you most of the value. Depending on the facts, recoveries under New York law can reach up to $60,000 or more; amounts are always case-specific and nothing can be promised. See our New York disability discrimination settlement amounts guide for how these are actually valued.
Mistake 3: Not Documenting the Incident Properly
Investigators work from records. A sincere account given a year later is worth a fraction of a photograph with a timestamp.
For a physical access barrier: photograph it from several angles, including something in frame for scale. Capture the absence of signage to an accessible entrance. Note the date, time, and exact location, and the name of any staff member you spoke to.
For a website or app barrier: screenshot the page that failed, record a short screen capture with your assistive technology running if you can, and save the URL and the date.
For an employment claim: this is the one people get wrong most often. Forward every relevant email to a personal account the day it arrives. People lose access to their work email on the day they are terminated, which is the exact day the record becomes most valuable. Save the accommodation request, the reply, the silence in between, the performance reviews from before you disclosed, and the write-ups from after.
For emotional distress: under the NYSHRL and NYCHRL you can recover for it, but only if it is evidenced. Medical appointments, medication changes, and a short contemporaneous log carry real weight. Our guide on how to prove disability discrimination at work in New York goes through what actually persuades an investigator.
Mistake 4: Filing in a Forum Without Knowing What You Give Up
This is the quietest and most expensive mistake on the list, because it feels like progress.
Filing a NYSHRL complaint with the New York State Division of Human Rights generally constitutes an election of remedies: you have chosen the administrative route and cannot later bring the same claim in court, subject to a narrow exception where the Division dismisses for administrative convenience.
Neither route is wrong. The agency route costs nothing, requires no lawyer to start, and is faster. The court route allows a jury, broader discovery, and in many cases larger awards. The mistake is making an irreversible choice without knowing you were making one. Decide first, file second.
Mistake 5: Skipping the Written Accommodation Request
In an employment accommodation case, the obligation generally does not attach until the employer knows you need something. If you never asked, there is often no denial to complain about.
The request does not need a form, a lawyer, or the words "ADA" or "reasonable accommodation." It needs three things: that you have a medical condition, what specific barrier it creates at work, and what change you are asking for. One paragraph by email is enough.
Two refinements that matter in New York. First, send it in writing even though a verbal request is legally valid, because a verbal request is nearly impossible to prove later. Second, if you work in the five boroughs, the NYCHRL requires your employer to engage in a cooperative dialogue and to give you a written final determination of what was granted or denied. An employer that simply goes silent has violated that obligation by the silence itself. Our guide to the ADA interactive process in New York covers each step.
One timing point: accommodation obligations run forward, not backward. An employer generally does not have to undo discipline for conduct that already occurred. Asking while your record is clean is far stronger than asking during a performance improvement plan.
Mistake 6: Misreading an Accessible Parking Problem
Accessible parking generates two very different situations, and people routinely bring the wrong one to the wrong place.
Not a discrimination claim: a lost, stolen, expired, or damaged parking permit or placard. Replacing one is an administrative matter handled by the government office that issued it. No discrimination complaint will get you a replacement, and filing one only costs you time.
Potentially a strong claim: a business or property that denies you the access the permit is supposed to enable. Examples include a store that has eliminated or blocked its accessible spaces, an accessible space whose adjacent access aisle is used for storage, deliveries, or snow piling so you cannot deploy a ramp or open a door fully, a garage that refuses to honor accessible parking, or a landlord or managing agent that refuses to assign you an accessible or closer parking space as a reasonable accommodation when one is available.
The second category is a public accommodation or housing claim under the ADA together with the NYSHRL and NYCHRL, and it is treated like any other access barrier: photograph it, date it, note the location, and get it reviewed. The mistake is assuming a parking problem is "just parking" rather than an access denial.
Mistake 7: Going Quiet After Retaliation
After you complain or file, a meaningful number of employers do something about it: a sudden write-up, a schedule change, duties stripped, a transfer, a termination. The instinct is to keep your head down and hope the original claim resolves.
That instinct forfeits a second claim. Retaliation for requesting an accommodation or filing a complaint is an independent violation with its own remedy, and it survives even if the underlying accommodation was lawfully denied. Retaliation claims are often easier to prove than the original discrimination, because the timing does much of the work. Document it the day it happens and report it. Our guide to ADA retaliation in New York explains how these cases are built.
Where to File: Agencies and Deadlines
- New York State Division of Human Rights. NYSHRL complaints statewide, covering employment, housing, and public accommodations. Generally three years for acts occurring on or after February 15, 2024. Note the election of remedies rule above.
- NYC Commission on Human Rights. NYCHRL complaints in the five boroughs, generally within one year, and three years for gender-based harassment.
- EEOC. Federal ADA employment charges, generally within 300 days in New York. A right-to-sue notice starts a 90-day clock to file in federal court.
- Court. NYSHRL and NYCHRL claims generally carry a three-year statute of limitations.
If you are not certain which of these fits your situation, that uncertainty is itself a reason to get it reviewed rather than to guess.
What to Do Next
Three steps, in this order:
- Write down the date of the first discriminatory act. Every deadline above runs from it.
- Move your evidence out of your work accounts and into a personal folder today: photos, emails, write-ups, the accommodation request and any reply.
- Get the claim reviewed before you file anything, because the forum choice is hard to undo.
ADA Help offers a free 3-minute case check at ada-help.org. You answer a short set of questions about what happened, and we tell you whether it looks like a claim, which law and which agency fit it, which deadline applies to you, and what to preserve. There is no cost and no obligation.
ADA Help is a case management service. We manage the claim end to end, track the deadlines, and connect you with independent New York attorneys who handle the legal work on a no recovery, no fee basis. You pay nothing up front to find out where you stand.
ADA Help is a case management service, not a law firm. Legal work is performed by independent New York attorneys. This article is general information, not legal advice.
Discriminated against in New York because of a disability?
A free three-minute check tells you if you can pursue a claim.
Check my case →New York onlyNo upfront costIndependent NY attorneysFree 3-minute check


