NY disability discrimination claimsFree to check

Employer Cannot Accommodate Work Restrictions: NY Rights

13 min readEmployment
New York onlyNY State, City & federal disability law.
No upfront costPay nothing unless you recover.
Independent NY attorneysLicensed NY attorneys, on contingency.
Free 3-minute checkSee if you have a claim, and what it’s worth.

Reviewed for accuracy by the ADAhelp team before publishing. ADAhelp is not a law firm; legal work is handled by independent New York attorneys.

Flat editorial illustration in navy, coral and cream of a desk with a clipboard holding a doctor's note and a pair of work gloves set aside, with stepping stones leading past a closed door toward an open one, and no people.

Employer says it cannot accommodate your work restrictions? What New York law requires next: reassignment, leave, and when a refusal becomes a real claim.

You hand HR a note from your doctor: no lifting over twenty pounds, no ladders, no shifts longer than eight hours. A week later you get the sentence that sends people searching at midnight — "we can't accommodate those restrictions." Sometimes it comes with an offer of unpaid leave. Sometimes it comes with a termination letter attached. Either way it lands like a verdict, and it is usually not one.

"We can't accommodate that" is a conclusion, not an analysis. Under federal and New York law, your employer has to do actual work before it reaches that conclusion, and the steps it skipped are often what turns a lost job into a claim. This guide explains what is supposed to happen when restrictions cannot be met in your current role, how long an employer has to accommodate you, when an accommodation can be withdrawn, and what your options look like in New York. ADA Help is a case management service, not a law firm, and the free 3-minute case check tells you whether your situation is worth pursuing.

The Short Answer

If your employer genuinely cannot accommodate your work restrictions in your current position, the law does not let it stop there. It must first consider reassignment to a vacant position you are qualified for, and leave as an accommodation, before separation is on the table. An employer that skips those steps — or that never explored alternatives with you at all — may have violated the ADA and New York's human rights laws, even if the original restrictions really were impossible to meet in your old role.

Key Takeaways

  • "We can't accommodate you" has to be the end of a process, not a substitute for one. The employer must identify which essential functions your restrictions block and why no adjustment works.
  • Reassignment to a vacant position you are qualified for is itself a reasonable accommodation under the ADA, and it is the step employers most often skip.
  • Leave can be a reasonable accommodation when it is finite and likely to let you return. Indefinite leave generally is not.
  • An employer can usually withdraw an accommodation, but only through the same good-faith process, and not as punishment for having asked.
  • Workers' compensation restrictions and the ADA are separate systems. Being cleared for "light duty" under one does not resolve your rights under the other.
  • Deadlines are short. An EEOC charge in New York is generally due within 300 days of the discriminatory act. A free case check costs nothing, and our case management is contingency-based: no recovery, no fee.

What Your Employer Is Supposed to Do First

Title I of the ADA applies to employers with 15 or more employees and requires reasonable accommodation for qualified employees with disabilities unless it would cause an undue hardship. New York's state human rights law applies to employers of every size, and the New York City law applies to employers with four or more employees — so even a small employer that falls outside the ADA almost certainly has obligations here.

Before an employer can say your restrictions cannot be met, it has to do three things. First, identify the essential functions of your job, as opposed to the marginal ones. Second, determine which of those functions your restrictions actually prevent. Third, explore adjustments: equipment, a modified schedule, reassigning a marginal duty to someone else, a different workstation, or help with a specific task. Only after that does "no accommodation is possible in this role" mean anything.

In practice, the analysis often collapses at step one. A restriction on lifting is treated as disqualifying for a job where lifting is occasional rather than central. A no-ladders restriction is treated as fatal when ladder work is five percent of the week and a coworker already does most of it. If no one ever asked you which parts of the job you could still do, that absence is the problem. Our guide to the ADA interactive process in New York covers what that conversation is supposed to look like, and reasonable accommodation examples in New York shows the range of adjustments that count.

Reassignment: The Step That Gets Skipped

When no accommodation makes your current job workable, reassignment to a vacant position is the next accommodation on the list, not a favor. Under the ADA it is generally treated as the accommodation of last resort, which means it comes before separation, not after. You must be qualified for the position, and it must be vacant or becoming vacant within a reasonable time.

What an employer is not required to do: create a new position, eliminate an essential function of the new role, promote you, or displace another employee to make room. What it also is not required to do in most federal cases is simply let you apply and compete — though several courts have held that a qualified employee should be placed rather than forced into an open competition. If your employer told you to "check the careers page like everyone else," write down who said it and when. That sentence does a lot of work in an accommodation case.

Ask for reassignment explicitly and in writing. Ask what vacancies exist, including part-time and lower-graded roles, and say you are willing to consider them. A documented request the employer never answered is far stronger than a general sense that they should have offered something.

Leave as an Accommodation — and Its Limits

If the restrictions are temporary, leave is often the accommodation that fits: time to finish treatment, heal from surgery, or stabilize a medication change, then a return to the same job. Leave can be a reasonable accommodation under the ADA even after FMLA entitlement is exhausted, and even if company policy caps leave at a fixed number of weeks. Rigid maximum-leave policies applied automatically, with no individual analysis, are a recurring source of claims.

The limit is indefiniteness. An employer generally does not have to hold a job open with no expected return date. The practical difference is whether your request has an end point: "my surgeon expects me cleared in ten weeks, with a follow-up on the 14th" is a request the law takes seriously. "I don't know when I'll be back" is much harder. If your doctor can give an estimate, get it in writing, even if it needs updating later. See ADA leave of absence in New York and FMLA versus ADA in New York for how the two tracks interact.

Be careful about leave used as a shortcut. Pushing you onto unpaid leave when a simpler adjustment would have let you keep working is not an accommodation; it is a cost shifted onto you. If that is what happened, ask in writing why the adjustment you proposed was rejected.

How Long Does an Employer Have to Accommodate You?

There is no fixed number of days in the statute. The obligation lasts as long as you are a qualified employee with a disability who needs the accommodation, and as long as providing it does not become an undue hardship. An accommodation that worked for two years does not expire because a new manager arrived.

What the law does require is reasonable promptness in responding. Unexplained delay — weeks of silence, repeated requests for more paperwork, a meeting that never gets scheduled — can itself be treated as a failure to accommodate. New York City goes further: the NYCHRL requires an employer to engage in a cooperative dialogue and then provide a written final determination identifying any accommodation granted or denied. If your employer never put its answer in writing, that is a standalone problem under the city law.

Can an Employer Take Away a Reasonable Accommodation?

Sometimes, yes — but not casually, and not quietly. An employer may revisit an accommodation if circumstances genuinely change: the role changes, the accommodation stops being effective, your limitations change, or the burden becomes significant in a way it was not before. When that happens, the employer owes you the same interactive process it owed the first time, including a look at alternatives before anything is withdrawn.

What is not permitted is removal as pressure or payback. Warning signs worth documenting: an accommodation pulled right after you filed a complaint or asked for something else; a new manager revoking an arrangement with no explanation; "we're standardizing" offered as the only reason; or the accommodation disappearing alongside a sudden change in your reviews. A withdrawal that follows protected activity can support a retaliation claim in its own right. See ADA retaliation claims in New York and performance improvement plans after disclosing a disability.

Work Restrictions, Light Duty, and Workers' Compensation

If your restrictions came out of a workplace injury, you are standing in two systems at once. Workers' compensation handles wage replacement and medical treatment for the injury. The ADA and New York's human rights laws handle whether you get to keep working. They use different words for similar things, and the overlap causes real confusion.

Two points matter most. An employer that maintains light-duty positions generally cannot reserve them only for people injured on the job while refusing them to employees whose restrictions come from any other condition. And a workers' compensation determination does not decide your discrimination claim — being found able to perform "light duty" under one system says nothing final about whether your employer met its accommodation obligations under the other. If you were cleared for modified work and told no modified work exists, ask for that in writing, along with a list of what was considered.

If You Were Fired Instead

Termination after restrictions are submitted is one of the most common patterns we see, and the timeline is usually the heart of the case. Write down the dates: when you gave notice of the restrictions, who received them, what was said in response, what alternatives were discussed, when vacancies existed, and when the separation happened. A termination that follows a documented request with no reassignment search and no written determination looks very different from one that follows a real process.

Which law you file under affects what is available. ADA damages are capped by employer size, from up to $50,000 for the smallest covered employers to up to $300,000 for the largest. The NYSHRL and NYCHRL do not cap compensatory damages, which is often why New Yorkers have more room under state and city law. Recovery amounts vary widely by case and no outcome can be predicted. For more, see wrongful termination due to disability in New York and whether you can be fired for a health condition in New York.

Deadlines decide more cases than facts do. An EEOC charge in New York is generally due within 300 days of the discriminatory act. A New York State Division of Human Rights complaint is generally due within three years for acts on or after February 15, 2024, and a New York City Commission on Human Rights complaint is generally due within one year. Filing an administrative complaint under the state or city human rights law can bar you from later bringing the same claim in court, so the forum choice should be made deliberately at the start, not discovered afterward. Our guide to ADA claim deadlines in New York lays them out side by side.

What to Do Next

Three things, in order. Put your restrictions and your accommodation request in writing if they are not already — email is enough. Ask explicitly, in writing, about reassignment to any vacant position and about leave with a return date. Then start the free 3-minute case check at ada-help.org; it costs nothing and tells you whether there is a claim worth pursuing.

If there is, we organize the evidence, build the timeline, identify which of the three laws fit your facts, prepare the paperwork, and file with the appropriate agency, tracking response dates so nothing lapses. ADA Help is a case management and intake service, not a law firm; when a matter needs legal representation, it is handled by independent New York attorneys. You never pay us out of pocket — our model is contingency-based: no recovery, no fee.

Frequently Asked Questions

What happens if my employer cannot accommodate my work restrictions?

Your employer must first show that no adjustment makes your current job workable, then consider reassignment to a vacant position you are qualified for, and consider leave as an accommodation if your restrictions are temporary. Separation comes last. If your employer went straight from your doctor's note to an offer of unpaid leave or a termination, the steps it skipped are usually the basis of a claim.

Can I sue my employer for not accommodating my disability?

You may have a claim, but in most cases you start with an administrative charge rather than a lawsuit. In New York that means the EEOC, the New York State Division of Human Rights, or the New York City Commission on Human Rights, and the choice matters because filing with a state or city agency can bar the same claim in court later. A free case check will tell you which route fits your facts and whether your deadlines are still open.

How long does an employer have to accommodate a disability?

There is no fixed time limit. The duty lasts as long as you are a qualified employee who needs the accommodation and providing it is not an undue hardship. An accommodation does not expire because time has passed or because management changed. Separately, the employer has to respond to a request reasonably promptly; long unexplained delays can themselves be a failure to accommodate.

Can an employer take away a reasonable accommodation?

Only through a legitimate, documented process. If circumstances genuinely change, an employer may revisit the accommodation, but it owes you the same interactive exchange and has to consider alternatives before withdrawing anything. Removing an accommodation because you complained, asked for something else, or got a new supervisor is a different matter and can support a retaliation claim.

How long can a reasonable accommodation last?

Indefinitely, if it continues to be needed and continues to be reasonable. Some accommodations are permanent, such as assistive equipment or a modified workstation. Others are temporary by design, such as leave for a treatment cycle or a reduced schedule during recovery. There is no automatic end date, and a policy that caps accommodations at a set number of weeks without individual review is a common source of claims.

Can an employer deny an ADA accommodation request?

Yes, for reasons the law recognizes: you cannot perform the essential functions even with the accommodation, the accommodation would not address your limitation, or it would cause significant difficulty or expense given the employer's size and resources. The employer carries the burden of showing undue hardship, and it must still consider alternatives, including reassignment, before concluding that nothing can be done.

Does being cleared for light duty mean my employer has to give me a job?

Not automatically, but it narrows the argument considerably. If your employer maintains light-duty positions, it generally cannot reserve them only for workers injured on the job while denying them to employees with restrictions from other conditions. And a workers' compensation clearance does not resolve your rights under the ADA or New York's human rights laws. Ask in writing what modified roles were considered and why each was rejected.

ADA Help is a case management service, not a law firm. Legal work is performed by independent New York attorneys. This article is general information, not legal advice.

Discriminated against in New York because of a disability?

A free three-minute check tells you if you can pursue a claim.

Check my case →

New York onlyNo upfront costIndependent NY attorneysFree 3-minute check

Free 3-minute check
Check my case →